
Is reconciliation between two people possible without naming the ways you've hurt each other or, as some say, "dredging up the past"?
Two recent experiences evoke Flannista's question.
The first experience is with my blood sister -- the one who recently learned that her thyroid cancer was benign; the one who more than three years ago at an infamous family reunion said with eerie and calm conviction (not once, but three times): "I'm counting on an assassin for Obama". At that time, she also invited me "to do what we've always needed you to do which is to keep your mouth shut."
This past July 3, I received -- out of the blue -- the following text message from her:
I need to see you, to make amends. To speak of this after my surgery face to face. Over the phone or text will not do it justice . . . I would love to see you and talk. For now know that I am so sorry and I love you! I have been doing a life review and boy do I need to ask for forgiveness for so many things from childhood to adulthood.
I was skeptical. The morning Matissta and I left for my high school reunion in Pennsylvania, I texted this sister and said that I would be in the area, hoping that she had already made plans for the weekend so I could avoid seeing her. She immediately texted me back and said that she would drive to the B&B where we were staying the very next morning.
The next morning, we talked for more than two hours. During that time, my sister methodically recounted specific episodes of abuse from our childhood and apologized for them. With the same specificity, she then recounted the infamous family reunion and point-by-point apologized for what she said that day and how she orchestrated making me the scapegoat for a disastrous time. She explained why she did it, but in no instance, let herself off the hook. She asked me to express my anger. She sat there and listened and apologized again. She then asked for my forgiveness. She then acknowledged that we would have to talk several more times to ensure the forgiveness between us. I was impressed and left speechless. Our encounter was painful and difficult, but ultimately healing.
The second experience is with a long-time friend, one with whom I had not spoken to face to face since the middle of May though she lives in the area. Over the course of the year, we had both neglected and/or hurt the other. I felt it was time to attempt to move past this pain and a week ago, suggested we meet for lunch. After exchanging a few pleasantries at a restaurant, I said, "I am broken-hearted about our friendship." The friend said, hesitatingly, "Okay . . . ." I then continued:
FLANN: You broke my heart when you didn't call me when Gwen died.
FRIEND: I am not going to bring up the past. We are not going there.
FLANN: But how can we move forward if we don't understand how we hurt each other?
FRIEND: I am not going to sit here and listen to a recitation of mistakes. I will not look at the past.
FLANN: But I don't know how . . .
FRIEND: You can try any way you want to to get to the past, but I am not going there and if you continue, I am leaving.
We managed to stay together for the next hour and a half, and I did apologize, at one point "for being an a$$hole" about any number of things that I don't remember at the moment. She never acknowledged any mistakes and neither offered any apologies. Bottom line, I was left intimidated and confused. She suggested we get together for lunch this week, but after thinking about it, I called her and said:
I do not know how to repair a relationship without taking a hard look at how we have hurt each other which entails looking at the past which you are unwilling to do. I cannot move forward when both of us are unable to struggle to name the truth as we perceive it (however correctly or incorrectly). This does not work for me, so I think we ought to keep the "pause button" pressed a bit longer.
She said that she had been "coming to the same conclusion." I have no idea when we will speak and/or see each other again.
Two attempts at reconciliation. Two different outcomes.
Two days ago, I shared what happened with my friend with my blood sister. She replied, "I'm so sorry, Flannista, but we both know that time is the great healer, don't we?"
Recent Comments