
Is ghostwriting a book ethical?
Two weeks ago, a former client gave Flannista's name to the executive director (ED) of a large evangelical business leadership organization who needed a ghostwriter for a book he wanted to write on how Christian leadership ethics can transform communities. I sent him an email telling him that I was not a ghostwriter but a "writing coach". He said he was still interested in talking to me and sent me a working outline for the book based on a template he had found on the internet. After we exchanged phone introductions and pleasantries, I asked him how I could help him:
ED: I talked out my perspectives about how different Christian leaders "lead" into a tape recorder and you would transcribe those recordings and turn them into chapters of the book.
FLANN: But I'm not a transcriber. I am a writer.
ED: Oh, so I would have to get a transcriber and then you would take the transcriptions and form them into chapters.
FLANN: It would be a better book if you took the transcriptions and then did a rough draft of the chapters that I would then edit.
ED: But I don't like to write. It's too hard.
FLANN: I don't like to write either, but I love having written.
ED: I don't love anything about it. It's too tedious, but God has called me to write this book.
FLANN: Well, if God wants you to write a book, don't you think you ought to actually write it?
ED: But I don't want to write it. It's too time-consuming. I need someone else to write it.
FLANN: So to be more accurate, God has called you to have an idea for a book, but not to write a book.
ED: Yes, precisely.
FLANN: Isn't that a little like Michelangelo coming up with the idea for the statue of David and then someone else actually sculpting it?
ED: But this isn't art. This is a book.
FLANN: You'll have to forgive me, but I have too much respect for the writer's unique voice not to believe that ghostwriting is unethical. Have you ever written anything before?
ED: Yes, I did a workbook on how businesspeople can become better leaders, but I hated writing it. I was only able to write a page a day.
FLANN: Wow. I'm so jealous. That's better than me and for that matter, writers like Eudora Welty and Ernest Hemingway. A page a day is great.
ED: Really? But it takes everything out of me. I just don't have the time or patience.
FLANN: But you do have a unique voice and perspective. I believe in that voice and perspective. I am an advocate for that voice and perspective. I am your advocate.
ED: But I don't want an advocate for my voice. I want a ghostwriter.
FLANN: Okay. I am not a ghostwriter. Let me email you the names of a couple of colleagues who may be interested in ghostwriting your book.
Was I too hard on ED? I've been thinking about this conversation a lot and would love your perspective.
Recent Comments